Appleton Creamery is one of the most decorated cheese makers in the state of Maine, winning many awards before the Guild organized and created a web site to document these awards. Below is a list of awards given before those already listed in Guild press releases that can be found on this web site:

2009

Second Place — Chevre in Brandied Grape Leaf — American Cheese Society
Bronze Medal — Georges Highland — Eastern States Exposition
Bronze Medal — Chevre in Olive Oil with Roasted Garlic & Herbs — Eastern States Exposition

2008

Second Place — Sophia Feta — American Cheese Society
Second Place — Chevre in Brandied Grape Leaf — American Cheese Society
Second Place — St. Bridget — American Dairy Goat Association
Third Place — Chevre in Olive Oil with Roasted Garlic & Herbs — American Dairy Goat Association

2007

First Place — sheeps milk yogurt –American Cheese Society
First Place– Chevre in Olive Oil with Roasted Garlic & Herbs — American Dairy Goat Association
Third Place– St. Bridget — American Dairy Goat Association .

2006

First Place — Chevre in Olive Oil with Roasted Garlic & Herbs –American Cheese Society
First Place — BreBrie –American Cheese Society
Second Place– Chevre in Olive Oil with Roasted Garlic & Herbs — American Dairy Goat Association .

2005

Second Place — sheeps milk yogurt –American Cheese Society

2004

First Place — Chevre in Brandied Grape Leaf –American Cheese Society
Third Place — Chevre in Olive Oil with Roasted Garlic & Herbs –American Cheese Society
First Place — Chevre in Olive Oil with Roasted Garlic & Herbs — American Dairy Goat Association

2003

First Place — Chevre in Olive Oil with Fresh Basil and Pine Nuts — American Cheese Society

1999

First Place — chevre buttons in olive oil — American Cheese Society
Second Place — chevre in olive oil with roasted garlic — American Cheese Society

1996

Bronze medal: Classic Plain
Bronze medal: Crofter’s
Silver medal: Crofter’s (total presentation)
Silver medal: Chevre in Olive Oil
Gold medal: Chevre in Grape Leaf